Thursday, March 12, 2015

Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880)

Madame Bovary was written over a period of five years and first appeared in France in 1856-1857. The book caused great controversy at the time and Flaubert was made to stand trial on the charge of writing an immoral novel, but was later acquitted.

Madame Bovary is Emma, a young, beautiful woman who 'escapes' from life on her father's farm by marrying Charles Bovary but finds only mediocrity where she expected passion and romance.

'And all the time, deep within her, she was waiting for something to happen. Like a shipwrecked sailor she scanned her solitude with desperate eyes for the sight of a white sail far off on the misty horizon. She had no idea what that chance would be, what wind would waft it to her, where it would set her ashore, whether it was a launch or a three-decker, laden with anguish or filled to the portholes with happiness. But every morning when she woke she hoped to find it there.'

One day the Bovary's receive an unexpected invitation to La Vaubyessard, the home of the rich Marquis and his wife, but the visit only serves to make Emma more unhappy with her own situation and,
  
'made a gap in her life, like those great chasms that a mountain-storm will sometimes scoop out in a single night.'

'Love, she believed, must come suddenly, with thunder and lightning, a hurricane from on high that swoops down into your life and turns it topsy-turvy, snatches away your will-power like a leaf, hurls you heart and soul into the abyss. She did not know how on the terrace of a house the rain collects in pools when the gutters are choked; she would have continued to feel quite safe had she not suddenly discovered a crack in the wall.'

Escaping into sentimental novels and fantasy she begins her downward spiral which ends in adultery and her destruction.


http://www.metmuseum.org/research/libraries-and-study-centers/in-circulation/2015/pictures-and-words


'Her attachment to him was a thing of idiocy, full of admiration for him, full of voluptuous pleasure for her, a drugged blessedness; and her soul sank deep in its intoxication, drowned and shrivelled up in it like the Duke of Clarence in his butt of malmsey.'

Flaubert certainly has a beautiful lyrical quality to his writing and there are parts of the  book where his phrases and descriptions leap from the page with precision and power but his underlying Realism casts a bleak and sometimes sordid shadow over parts of the narrative. But then again, adultery is a sordid subject.

'She seemed to have all the bitterness of life served up on her plate; the steam of the stew conjured up like fumes of nausea from the depths of her soul.'


Although I'd heard of this classic, it wasn't until I read a section about the author and Madame Bovary in the book  Invitation to the Classics that I decided I should read it:



'What makes Madame Bovary so powerful is not any mere accumulation of detail for its own sake. Rather its power comes through Flaubert's faithful observation of the physical, through which he mysteriously illuminates the spiritual. Every particularity lends insight either into the soul of Emma or the inadequacies of the world in which she lives. Herein lie the challenge and reward of the novel: nothing is superfluous; everything reveals meaning.'


Some other thoughts:


*  The fatalistic combination of social and environmental factors which dominates Thomas Hardy's writing is apparent in Flaubert's work, as is Fyodor Dostoyovesky's pre-occupation with the internal and psychological struggles of his characters, although Flaubert is less intense in this regard.


*   Madame Bovary is often compared to Tolstoy's Anna Karenina, which I haven't read so can't comment on, but Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton (1862-1937) is a book I have read which has a similar theme. In this compelling and haunting story the act of adultery never takes place, but that would have been the inevitable outcome had not circumstances intervened. 

I was quite happy to finish Madame Bovary and be done with Emma, although Flaubert's writing in itself was beautiful, but Ethan Frome ended too quickly for me. The story still lingers in my mind and I'll read it again one day but I don't think I'd return to Madame Bovary in a hurry.

This book is my choice of  A Classic in Translation in the Back to the Classics Challenge.









 







Wednesday, March 11, 2015

Keeping Company - Nature & Science Notebooks

Where science does not teach a child to wonder and admire it has perhaps no educative value. 

A Philosophy of Education by Charlotte Mason

We've started getting back into our regular bush ventures now that the weather is cooling down here,  but this past week we had some outings which weren't done with the intention of nature study, but it occurred anyhow. Bengy found a very large, fat eel while swimming with some friends at a local waterhole; Moozle & I came across a mother duck and three little ducklings in a stream nearby when I took her on a short bike ride; we all saw and identified a 'moor hen' and we sat watching & listening to some large ravens in the park yesterday when we met my eldest daughter for lunch.

Our 'intentional' nature study was diverted a little when I found this wasp nest on the wall outside. We have been studying insects and were going to find out more about bees or mosquitoes until I saw this wasp nest - a ready made opportunity for study:




Insect Life in Australasia by William Gillies is our main book for studying insects but we also use The Handbook of Nature Study by Anna Comstock and The Wonderland of Nature by Nuri Mass.




Bengy's Nature Journal:




 Australian Raven, Corvus corooides

 ...I think. Crows and ravens are difficult to distinguish but by the looks of the neck feathers on this one (they are longish) I think it's a raven.




Bengy's Science Notebook:






Dusky Moor Hen, Gallinula tenebrosa



Moozle has been experimenting with various coloured pencils to get the colouring right on the rainbow lorikeet, one of our most common native birds. The outline was done for her so she could concentrate on the colouring.




This is from our study of the Emperor Gum Moth












Characteristics of insects - the last sentence was meant to say that they had three types of mouths, not three mouths:




Exploring & having fun...


Friday, March 6, 2015

Our Week in Review


We started the week by going to see Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream. 


It was delightful. At first I was expecting to be disappointed when I read the blurb just before the play started, but I needn't have worried. It was a great deal of fun and Shakespeare's theme was kept intact:

Please put aside your 'preconceptions' of what A Midsummer Night's Dream is all about. Join me as we travel to 'Athens Beach,' NSW, Australia in the mid 1960's. It is summer and wealthy celebrity Theseus, aka 'The Duke,' is about to wed his love Hippolyta... 
Debbie Smith, Director




This was our first week of Term 2 of both Ambleside Online Years 4 & 8 so time for a new artist. We are looking at the work of John William Waterhouse and 'Thisbe' who stars in both A Midsummer Night's Dream and also Bulfinches' Age of Fable, is the first of his paintings we'll be studying.

Thisbe by John William Waterhouse, 1909


Moozle continues to read through Fabre's Story Book of Science and I've been adding videos and other resources on Pinterest. We've done up to Chapter XXXI at the time of writing.
Some of Fabre's ideas are outdated and that's where other resources are very useful. The same goes for Madame How & Lady Why by Charles Kingsley (which I read to her) but I really like that both books are written in literary language. I've also posted some things we have used on Pinterest for that book. 

We included some history with our earth science studies this week:




I've been aware of a number of connections this week. I love it when this type of learning happens and one thing relates to another without me trying to make it all happen.

When Moozle finished reading Fabre's chapters on venom, vipers & scorpions, I started to explain that we don't treat snake bite now in the way he described. Then she started telling me Fabre said that 'no animals can shoot venom and harm us from a distance but in Hal and Roger (characters in the Willard Price adventure novels) there was a spitting cobra!'
Then she proceeded to tell me all about the African Mamba.
All my kids loved reading these books around the age of 8 to 10 years & they're great books to get boys reading.


 

They also love the Biggles books by W.E. Johns. I'm saying this because both series get mentioned regularly. Moozle hasn't read any of the Willard Price books for a while but she still remembers so much about the animals and natural phenomena described in the books. Biggles even came up after we'd read a chapter of Madame How & Lady Why - apparently Biggles had a mission which necessitated flying over an English moor or something to that effect...



Free Reading - Moozle's reading of choice has been Anne of the Island and Anne of Avonlea by Lucy Maud Montgomery.

Bengy finished a biography of Billy Graham which he enjoyed and is now reading Jesus Among Other Gods by Ravi Zacharias, which he said is very good but requires a good deal of concentration. He picked up some lighter reading today when we paid an impromptu visit to a second hand book shop - The Saltzburg Connection by Helen MacInnes and a book in the Oregon Files series by Clive Cussler. He's read one book in this series & it was ok but I'd be cautious about some of the author's other books.

Read Aloud - I Can Jump Puddles by Alan Marshall. An Australian classic written in 1955 about the life of a young boy who contracts polio (Infantile Paralysis) in the early 1900's.


 Some cloud observations at sunset earlier in the week...


Nature Study - Insects with diversions into wedge-tailed eagles and emus, animals we have seen on our trips interstate
Reading The Story of Karrawingi the Emu by Leslie Rees to Moozle - excellent. Karrawingi had run ins with wedge-tailed eagles, black-breasted buzzards and a dingo.

An experiment on velocity...


My reading - just finished The Old Curiosity Shop by Charles Dickens; started Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert and continuing with Formation of Character by Charlotte Mason.
 And 'furnishing my mind' with some poetry...


When you are old and grey and full of sleep,
And nodding by the fire, take down this book,
And slowly read, and dream of the soft look
Your eyes had once, and of their shadows deep;

How many loved your moments of glad grace,
And loved your beauty with love false or true,
But one man loved the pilgrim soul in you,
And loved the sorrows of your changing face;

And bending down beside the glowing bars,
Murmur, a little sadly, how Love fled
And paced upon the mountains overhead
And hid his face amid a crowd of stars.
By William Butler Yeats ( 1865–1939)

                               





Weekly Wrap-Up


Thursday, March 5, 2015

The Old Curiosity Shop by Charles Dickens



When The Old Curiosity Shop was first published in serial form in 1840 to 1841, its Victorian readers were enamoured with it. The story became an immediate success and so I was a little surprised upon reading the book at how much less enjoyable I found it compared to other books I've read by Dickens.
Whilst still retaining his wonderful way with words and introducing some remarkable characters, Dickens unfortunately overwhelms the story with sentiment, especially in regards to the main character, Nell.
Nell and her Grandfather are reduced to poverty and are forced to flee from their home in the old shop. Begging as they go, they travel away from the city and into the unknown. While they are wandering around the countryside, the story returns to events back in the city and Nell disappears for long periods in the narrative. 
While she is sidelined, other characters appear who are more interesting, such as Quilp, the grotesque tyrant, evil and cunning

Quilp...ate hard eggs, shell and all, devoured gigantic prawns with the heads and tails on, chewed tobacco and water-cresses at the same time and with extraordinary greediness, drank boiling tea without winking, bit his fork and spoon till they bent again, and in short performed so many horrifying and uncommon acts that the women were nearly frightened out of their wits, and began to doubt if he were really a human creature.

Richard Swiveller, an idle young man who regularly uses literary quotes to bemoan his fate, is a character who doesn't show much promise at first but his character develops and expands as the story progresses. And then there's the Marchioness, the mistreated 'small servant,' - nameless, parentless, locked up and deprived.

I mentioned in my post on A Tale of Two Cities that one of the delights of reading Dickens is his skilful ability to intertwine tragedy and humour. His clever juxtaposition of the two creates an atmosphere that makes for natural sympathy with his characters. This ability was less obvious in The Old Curiosity Shop.
    

G.K. Chesterton in Appreciations and Criticisms of the Work of Charles Dickens, made this observation regarding Dickens' use of pathos:

He strained himself to achieve pathos. His humour was inspiration; but his pathos was ambition. His laughter was lonely; he would have laughed on a desert island. But his grief was gregarious. He liked to move great masses of men, to melt them into tenderness, to play on the people as a great pianist plays on them; to make them mad or sad. His pathos was to him a way of showing his power; and for that reason it was really powerless. He could not help making people laugh; but he tried to make them cry. 

I agree with Chesterton that:

The real hero and heroine of The Old Curiosity Shop are of course Dick Swiveller and the Marchioness. It is significant in a sense that these two sane, strong, living, and lovable human beings are the only two, or almost the only two, people in the story who do not run after Little Nell. They have something better to do than to go on that shadowy chase after that cheerless phantom. They have to build up between them a true romance; perhaps the one true romance in the whole of Dickens. 


 http://www.stanwardine.com/cribbage.html

The short story, Dick Swiveller and the Marchioness, can be read online here.

'This poor little Marchioness has been wearing herself to death!’ cried Dick.
‘No I haven’t,’ she returned, ‘not a bit of it. Don’t you mind about me. I like sitting up, and I’ve often had a sleep, bless you, in one of them chairs. But if you could have seen how you tried to jump out o’ winder, and if you could have heard how you used to keep on singing and making speeches, you wouldn’t have believed it — I’m so glad you’re better, Mr Liverer.’
‘Liverer indeed!’ said Dick thoughtfully. ‘It’s well I am a liverer. I strongly suspect I should have died, Marchioness, but for you.’


















Tuesday, March 3, 2015

The Bible in Song - my blast from the past

The songs below were recorded by the Medical Mission Sisters in the 1960's. I learnt them when I was in primary school and loved them. I've taught what I remembered of them to my children but until recently, when I found them on youtube, I didn't have a recording of them.
Some of the words are available here.

The Parable of the Wedding Banquet: Matthew 22 & Luke 14.
This is our favourite & is fun to sing.





The story of Zacchaeus the tax collector: Luke 19




Luke 17 - this isn't the original recording & isn't the best quality but it's the only one I could find.




'Come down Lord my son is ill...Do not come to my house, I'm unworthy...'
Based on Matthew 8:





John 6 - a hymn I remember from years ago.




Not a Bible story as such but a song about Joy: